Cryptoheros cutteri is a small to medium-sized cichlid admired for its peaceful temperament and subtle yet attractive coloration. Its body is typically olive-brown to gray with hints of blue or green along the flanks, and the eyes often have a striking blue hue, giving the species its nickname, “Blue-Eye Cichlid.”

Males are slightly larger and may display more vivid coloration, especially around the fins, while females are smaller and more subdued. Adult size generally ranges 10–12 cm, making them suitable for medium-sized aquariums.